Poll: And the Oscar for Best Pizza Goes To …

Where in Eagle Rock do you find the best pizza?

During one of the lighter moments in the murder trial last year of LAFD Capt. David Del Toro, a witness called to the stand uttered the word “Casablanca” while alluding to the iconic, family-owned Italian eatery on Colorado Boulevard that is among Eagle Rock’s oldest restaurants.

The error may well have been permanently buried in court records were it not for an interjection from Lance Ito, the Silver Lake-born Superior Court judge who also handed the O.J. Simpson trial. “Casa Bianca,” Ito instantly corrected, and then added something to the effect that the restaurant is too well known to have its name so casually distorted for posterity.

Casa Bianca, which our Music and Culture columnist Dan Kimpel aptly described as "Eagle Rock's Mecca of Mozarella" in a 2010 article by the same title, is known for its pizzas. And not just because L.A. gastronome Jonathan Gold once described its pizza pies as the best in the Southland.

Not everyone agrees of course—and it’s one of the attractions of Eagle Rock as a destination for eating out that a variety of independently owned restaurants pride themselves on serving quality pizzas.

Which one do you think serves the best pizza in town? To put the question more broadly, where in Eagle Rock have you ever had the best-cooked pizza, including in pop-up gatherings such as the ones that Eagle Rock native and self-styled chef Michael Gerard of Wildwood Ovens is fond of hosting from time to time, most recently during the Eagle Rock Boulevard block party last November?

Take our poll below and vote for your favorite independently owned pizza place. (Feel free to tell us why in the Comments section below as well as make suggestions we might have overlooked.) The poll is open until 10 a.m. on Friday, March 2, after which a winner from the following choices will be announced—and awarded a Patch "Best Of" certificate, replete with bragging rights:

Note: Fatty's, the renowned restaurant on Colorado Boulevard, was added late Monday to the poll after a reader suggested that it serves delicious pizza, including one named the Zeppelin. The late head start for Fatty's might explain the relatively lower number of votes for it.

Tracy King February 27, 2012 at 08:03 PM
Wildwood ovens. Amazing pizza.
Yvette Garcia March 01, 2012 at 01:07 AM
The Capri is a family staple - and has been for several years, we have even celebrated many birthdays for almost everyone in my family! It has only gotten better with their new and healthy dishes - LOVE the pizza of course ;) ;) The boys and staff are always welcoming and treat you like you're part of the family! Happy belly's ALWAYS - the Garcia family from Bakersfield!!!
Dianne Ennis March 02, 2012 at 05:08 PM
The Capri is not the same since the guy from NY came and messed with the menu. I do agree it needed to be cleaned up and he did a good job with that...but the pizza is too greasy, the grease sits on top. Some of the really good items we use to order are no longer available...AND if I want to eat healthy...I'll stay home. When we go out to eat I want to have fun and eat good food that is full of flavor and leaves me wanting to come back for more. The garlic knots are to die for ...but ya gotta have more than that going for ya. And the portions served...reeally? I love the guys and the servers and the restrauant looks amazing...the food...not so much.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »